Hi all, and apologies for the delay in posting again.
We met last Wednesday to read from 007.20 to 013.04, delving primarily into the history of the United Kingdom (and of Ireland) in the Wellingdone "museyroom". ("Mind your hats goan in!")
Aside from Wellington's "big white harse", a little bit the body, and a little bit his horse Copenhagen (thanks Jamie for this titbit), there remains, I believe, a bit of a conflict in this section. The conflict is in the multitude of settings that the reader is supposed to anticipate here: So, aside from the museum itself, the text also inhabits the dream of HCE, hence the "tip"ing at the window, the tapping of a tree branch against a window.
The martial allusions that Joyce pursues are more clear: from World War One references to the Battle of Philippi in 42 BC. The breadth of Joyce's allusions calls to mind another question for me though: if Joyce is not merely examining British (and Irish) martial history, then the museum is a much more extended space than we may have anticipated.
Aside from these questions, we liked the rhythm that Joyce produces on p. 8, both from ll. 11-14, in which he begins from a simple(ish) statement, then growing more complicated, before returning to some simplicity at the end, perhaps at odds to the counting of 010.32-34.
ALP's appearance (dreamed or otherwise) was our final focus of the reading. Lachlan explained the image of ALP as hen, pecking away at the scrap heap, in hindsight approximating the "tip" that Joyce repeats throughout the museum section. The lightning and thunder of p. 11 suggest a precursor to the fall of HCE that we're all anticipating; a fall that may perhaps be repeated eternally if a phrase such as "to steal out historic presents from the past postpropheticals" (011.30-31) is as significant as it appears.
Of course, there's not only cyclical views of history on show, but biblical allusions as well, as Noah's flood is made reference to shortly after. And finally we're left with the (despairing) exclamation "So This Is Dyoublong?", not just encapsulating some disappointment at the provincial nature of Dublin, but also asking do we belong?
As always comments are most welcome! I'd love some additions to my free association rambling!
A number of other notices:
Miri is doing a short performance as part of the UNSW postgrad symposium—a piece on Anna Livia, including excerpts from the Wake. On at the Dance Studio, Webster Building, 6:45, Friday 9 September.
A colleague, and potential reading group member, Chris Eagle, will be presenting a paper on the Wake to the Writing and Society Research Group on Wednesday the 28th of September from 11 to 12:30 in room 1.1.119, just down the corridor from where we meet.
Also, you may have seen a review of a new Joyce biography by Gordon Bowker, in Review. Not very positive—I'll stick with Ellmann for the time being! Review HERE.
We're reading from 013.05 to 021.04, meeting Wednesday 7 September at 1. Hope to see you there!
A space for the academic and non-academic universes to collide to take on Joyce's Finnegans Wake.
Tuesday, 30 August 2011
Friday, 12 August 2011
003.01 to 007.19 (!?!)
Greetings! I'm here to report on the first meeting of our Finnegans Wake reading group.
I must admit I found the whole process rather confronting. In my reading of the Wake in preparation I'd been keeping some pretty extensive notes, and was convinced that I'd built a pretty compelling take on the novel that put Nietzsche's concept of eternal return front and centre, albeit a reading that was based on a couple of introductory essays, and 16 pages of the actual text itself!
But...that's not really how it goes. The group reading allows (and promotes) a much more multifocal reading of the text. So, so much for my absolute interpretation.
I think I (we) learnt two things today. The first was that the Wake sounds great when you read it aloud. Even better than when you're reading it in your head. Lou was adamant before the meeting that reading it aloud pushes you into an Irish brogue, and Miri showed us that very effectively in what was definitely the highlight of the readings we heard. I also have a feeling, although I'll need to give this some more thought that the portmanteau words operate differently when they're spoken as opposed to when they're read. There's something in there about the operation of metaphor, and perhaps even the metaphoric nature of language, but I'll leave that for another time.
The other thing that was quickly obvious is that a knowledge of the narrative of the Wake may be quite important for reading the text. I was maintaining a (probably) naive view that I would hold out, and glean the narrative from the text. Our two most experienced campaigners were adamant, however, that recourse to the narrative is crucial in understanding the text. For a text that has simultaneously so many, and so few handholds, I daresay they're right.
Anyway, much more to learn, that's for sure. Next time (1 pm Wednesday 24 August) we'll reading from 007.20 to 013.04 (or thereabouts). Let me know your thoughts by signing up and commenting.
Hope to see you all next time! JG
Oh and have a listen to this. Dropkick Murphy's are always relevant!
I must admit I found the whole process rather confronting. In my reading of the Wake in preparation I'd been keeping some pretty extensive notes, and was convinced that I'd built a pretty compelling take on the novel that put Nietzsche's concept of eternal return front and centre, albeit a reading that was based on a couple of introductory essays, and 16 pages of the actual text itself!
But...that's not really how it goes. The group reading allows (and promotes) a much more multifocal reading of the text. So, so much for my absolute interpretation.
I think I (we) learnt two things today. The first was that the Wake sounds great when you read it aloud. Even better than when you're reading it in your head. Lou was adamant before the meeting that reading it aloud pushes you into an Irish brogue, and Miri showed us that very effectively in what was definitely the highlight of the readings we heard. I also have a feeling, although I'll need to give this some more thought that the portmanteau words operate differently when they're spoken as opposed to when they're read. There's something in there about the operation of metaphor, and perhaps even the metaphoric nature of language, but I'll leave that for another time.
The other thing that was quickly obvious is that a knowledge of the narrative of the Wake may be quite important for reading the text. I was maintaining a (probably) naive view that I would hold out, and glean the narrative from the text. Our two most experienced campaigners were adamant, however, that recourse to the narrative is crucial in understanding the text. For a text that has simultaneously so many, and so few handholds, I daresay they're right.
Anyway, much more to learn, that's for sure. Next time (1 pm Wednesday 24 August) we'll reading from 007.20 to 013.04 (or thereabouts). Let me know your thoughts by signing up and commenting.
Hope to see you all next time! JG
Oh and have a listen to this. Dropkick Murphy's are always relevant!
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
No More Rumbling!
After much organisational to-ing and fro-ing, we begin the reading group tomorrow.
We are meeting at 1 pm, 10 August at UWS Bankstown, in the Writing and Society Research Group's new meeting room 1.1.131.
We're biting off more than we can chew—seven pages of the Wake. We're reading from 003.01 to 010.24. (Three digit page number, followed by two digit line number) I dare say the last word may feel very appropriate!
After our meeting I'll post a summary of what was discussed, and some of my thoughts on the section, for those playing at home.
JG
We are meeting at 1 pm, 10 August at UWS Bankstown, in the Writing and Society Research Group's new meeting room 1.1.131.
We're biting off more than we can chew—seven pages of the Wake. We're reading from 003.01 to 010.24. (Three digit page number, followed by two digit line number) I dare say the last word may feel very appropriate!
After our meeting I'll post a summary of what was discussed, and some of my thoughts on the section, for those playing at home.
JG
Tuesday, 14 June 2011
Pre-Bloomsday Rumblings
Greetings again!
As you may very well know, Bloomsday is almost upon us! Bloomsday is a commemoration of the day that Ulysses takes place on, the 16th of July 1904. The biggest Bloomsday event that I'm aware of will be held at the Gaelic Club in Surry Hills. More info can be found HERE.
You may have also noticed Don Anderson's review of the new edition of Finnegans Wake in 'Review' from The Australian's arts pages. The new edition, launched at the Sydney Writer's Festival, includes around 9000 emendations that seek to provide the definitive edition of Joyce's intentions for the text. I like the humour with which Anderson approaches the impossibilities of summarising Joyce's text. Although the cheapest edition of the new version isn't going to come cheap at 250 pounds...
Anyways, I'll be sending the official e-mail out in the next couple of weeks to begin the challenge of reading the thing! Just got to mark my essays...
As you may very well know, Bloomsday is almost upon us! Bloomsday is a commemoration of the day that Ulysses takes place on, the 16th of July 1904. The biggest Bloomsday event that I'm aware of will be held at the Gaelic Club in Surry Hills. More info can be found HERE.
You may have also noticed Don Anderson's review of the new edition of Finnegans Wake in 'Review' from The Australian's arts pages. The new edition, launched at the Sydney Writer's Festival, includes around 9000 emendations that seek to provide the definitive edition of Joyce's intentions for the text. I like the humour with which Anderson approaches the impossibilities of summarising Joyce's text. Although the cheapest edition of the new version isn't going to come cheap at 250 pounds...
Anyways, I'll be sending the official e-mail out in the next couple of weeks to begin the challenge of reading the thing! Just got to mark my essays...
Wednesday, 18 May 2011
The First Rumblings...
Welcome!
This blog is intended both as companion, and as a stand-alone space for a group project to attempt the impossible...to read the entirety of Finnegans Wake.
I'm (hopefully) a little bit naive, but believe that it's possible to tap into the vastness of Joyce's novel (if that's the right word) and make it accessible and interesting both to people in the academic community (this shouldn't be too hard) but also to people not involved in the academy in any way.
The only thing I can guarantee is perserverance—I'm intent on reading the entirety of the Wake because, no matter how stupid it sounds, I'm embarassed I haven't read it yet.
Meetings will run at UWS Bankstown (hopefully in the Writing and Society Research Group's new meeting space) beginning in a month or two.
I will update this blog with my impressions and all feedback and suggestions I receive. I will also attempt to provide a nuanced reading of the section we will read each week, and provide links, or guidance, to extra material that assists in grasping the text.
Any text of Finnegans Wake is appropriate for reading the work. For reference I will be referring to the latest bog standard Penguin Classics version which cost me twenty bucks on the net.
You can buy a new copy HERE.
Or for the student population, second hand copies HERE.
For more information, e-mail me at j dot gourley at uws dot edu dot au.
And for a touch of Joycean humour, check out this short film from the Irish Film Board on Joyce and his golfing buddy, Samuel Beckett.
This blog is intended both as companion, and as a stand-alone space for a group project to attempt the impossible...to read the entirety of Finnegans Wake.
I'm (hopefully) a little bit naive, but believe that it's possible to tap into the vastness of Joyce's novel (if that's the right word) and make it accessible and interesting both to people in the academic community (this shouldn't be too hard) but also to people not involved in the academy in any way.
The only thing I can guarantee is perserverance—I'm intent on reading the entirety of the Wake because, no matter how stupid it sounds, I'm embarassed I haven't read it yet.
Meetings will run at UWS Bankstown (hopefully in the Writing and Society Research Group's new meeting space) beginning in a month or two.
I will update this blog with my impressions and all feedback and suggestions I receive. I will also attempt to provide a nuanced reading of the section we will read each week, and provide links, or guidance, to extra material that assists in grasping the text.
Any text of Finnegans Wake is appropriate for reading the work. For reference I will be referring to the latest bog standard Penguin Classics version which cost me twenty bucks on the net.
You can buy a new copy HERE.
Or for the student population, second hand copies HERE.
For more information, e-mail me at j dot gourley at uws dot edu dot au.
And for a touch of Joycean humour, check out this short film from the Irish Film Board on Joyce and his golfing buddy, Samuel Beckett.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)